By Bar & Bench (March 30):
Bench of Justice Revati Mohite Dere of Bombay High Court recuses from hearing default bail pleas of Bhima Koregoan accused Mahesh Raut and 3 others.
Justice Revati Mohite Dere of Bombay HC recuses from hearing bail plea of Mahesh Raut, others
30/03/2023
India Legal / by India Legal
Justice Revati Mohite Dere of Bombay High Court on Thursday recused herself from hearing the default bail petitions of Mahesh Raut and three others, who were arrested for their alleged involvement in the Elgar Parishad Maoists links case of 2018.
Earlier on March 1, the High Court had issued notice to the National Investigation Agency (NIA) on the default bail plea of Raut, Sudhir Dhawale, Shoma Sen and Rona Wilson, who were arrested on June 6, 2018 under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act. Read more
Supreme Court reserves its judgment on bail pleas by Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira
04/03/2023
The Leaflet / by Sarah Thanawala
Senior advocate Rebecca M. John, representing Gonsalves, highlighted the commonality between Dr. Teltumbde’s grant of bail by the Bombay high court last year and the evidence in the present case to draw the claim of parity with the high court’s bail order.
On Friday, a division bench of the Supreme Court, comprising Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia, reserved its judgment on the bail applications of trade unionist, activist and academic Vernon Gonsalves, and activist and lawyer Arun Ferreira for the grant of regular bail. Gonsalves and Ferreira have filed bail applications at the Supreme Court challenging the order of the Bombay High Court dated October 15, 2019, rejecting their bail pleas. Read more
Supreme Court Reserves Verdict In Bail Pleas Of Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira
03/03/2023
Live Law / by Awstika Das
The Supreme Court on Friday reserved its verdict on the bail applications of Bhima Koregaon-accused and activists Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira, both of whom have been lodged in jail since August 2018 for alleged offences under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967…
Gonsalves and Ferreira have approached the Supreme Court against a December 2021 order by which the Bombay High Court denied them default bail, even as the same benefit was granted to another co-accused, Sudha Bharadwaj. Even though this order was questioned in a subsequent review petition preferred by the two petitioners, the high court, in May of last year, refused to grant them relief. Read more
Supreme Court reserves verdict on bail pleas of Vernon Gonsalves, Arun Ferreira
03/03/2023
Bar & Bench / by Abhimanyu Hazarika
The NIA opposed the bail plea stating that long period in custody cannot be a ground to show leniency to terror-accused.
The Supreme Court on Friday reserved its verdict on the bail applications filed by two accused in the Bhima Koregaon case, Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira [Vernon vs State of Maharashtra and anr].
A bench of Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia concluded hearing arguments today, and reserved its order. Read more
Bombay HC quashes order rejecting bail plea of Navlakha by special court, orders expeditious rehearing
03/03/2023
Sabrang / by Sabrangindia
… Today, in 2023, the Bombay High Court has ordered the case to be heard expeditiously. However, it has been years since the Bhima Koregaon accused have had their freedom stripped from them. There is every probability that the said special court will reject Navlakha’s bail plea again, and then an appeal will again be filed in the upper constitutional courts. Why then, keeping in view the pattern of misuse of the criminal justice system with the aim of harassing human rights defenders, could the High Court not take up the case themselves at this stage itself? Read more
Bombay High Court directs special NIA court to rehear Gautam Navlakha’s bail plea for want of analysis
03/03/2023
The Leaflet / by Sarah Thanawala
The bench directed the special court to conclude the hearing within four weeks.
On Thursday, a division bench of the Bombay High Court, comprising Justices A.S. Gadkari and P.D. Naik, refused to grant regular bail to Gautam Navlakha and directed the special court under National Investigation Agency (NIA) Act to rehear the bail plea for its reconsideration. The bench quashed the special court’s order dated September 5, 2022 that rejected the grant of regular bail to Navlakha. Read more
Bombay High Court quashes NIA court order rejecting bail to Gautam Navlakha; directs rehearing
02/03/2023
Bar & Bench / by Neha Joshi
The High Court opined that the reasoning in the lower court order was very cryptic and did not have analysis of the evidence relied upon by prosecution.
The Bombay High Court on Thursday quashed an order by the special court under the National Investigation Agency (NIA) Act rejecting bail to Bhima Koregaon accused Gautam Navlakha and directed the special judge to rehear the bail plea [Gautam Navlakha v. National Investigation Agency & Ors.]. Read more
Pen mightier than sword but won’t strike terror: Counsel for Gautam Navlaka seeking bail in Bombay High Court
02/03/2023
The Leaflet / by Sarah Thanawala
Advocate Yug M. Chaudhary, appearing for Navlakha, challenged Navlakha’s connection with the alleged terrorist acts.
ON Wednesday, a division bench of the Bombay High Court, comprising Justices A.S. Gadkari and P.D. Naik, continued hearing the regular bail application of Gautam Navlakha. Journalist and human rights activist Navlakha, an accused in the Bhima Koregaon-Elgar Parishad Maoist links/criminal conspiracy case, is charged under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA). Read more
Bombay High Court Sets Aside Special Court’s “Cryptic” Order Refusing Bail To Gautam Navlakha, Directs To Decide Afresh
02/03/2023
Live Law / by Amisha Shrivastava
Observing that the trial court gave cryptic reasoning while refusing Bhima Koregaon accused Gautam Navlakha’s bail plea, the Bombay High Court on Thursday directed the Special NIA Court to hear and decide the case afresh.
The division bench of Justice AS Gadkari and Justice PD Naik set aside the Special NIA Court’s order rejecting Navlakha’s bail plea. Read more Read/Download Impugned Order
Supreme Court continues hearing the bail pleas of Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira
02/03/2023
The Leaflet / by Sarah Thanawala
Additional Solicitor General K.M. Nataraj, representing the National Investigation Agency, alleges involvement of Gonsalves and Ferreira in alleged terrorist acts through letters and documents.
On Wednesday, a division bench of the Supreme Court, comprising Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia, continued hearing arguments on behalf of trade unionist, activist and academic Vernon Gonsalves, and activist and lawyer Arun Ferreira for the grant of regular bail. Gonsalves and Ferreira have filed bail applications at the Supreme Court challenging the order of the Bombay High Court dated October 15, 2019, rejecting their bail pleas. Read more
‘Show Us Where They Asked People To Pick Up Guns’, Supreme Court Tells NIA In Bail Pleas Of Accused
02/03/2023
Live Law / by Astika Das
Show us where the Bhima Koregaon-accused Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira encouraged others they allegedly ‘recruited’ to pick up arms against the the government, the Supreme Court told the National Investigation Agency on Wednesday. A division bench of Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia was hearing the bail applications of Gonsalves and a co-accused, Arun Ferreira, both of whom have been lodged in jail since August 2018 for charges under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.
… After hearing the submissions of senior advocates Rebecca John (for Gonsalves), R. Basant (for Ferreira), and the additional solicitor-general, the bench decided to adjourn the hearing till Friday, March 3. Read more
Delay In Starting Trial Not Due To Us, NIA Tells Supreme Court
01/03/2023
Live Law / by Awstika Das
The National Investigation Agency told the Supreme Court on Wednesday that the delay in the trial of the Bhima Koregaon accused could not be attributed to them. Additional Solicitor General for India K.M. Nataraj told the court.
… Notably, the trial in this high-profile case has not yet begun. Senior advocates Rebecca John (for Gonsalves) and R. Basant (for Ferreira) have both pointed out that even charges have not been framed yet, despite the passage of almost five years… In this connection, also relevant are Basant’s remarks on the delay in the process. He pointed out, “They intend to examine a total of 336 witnesses and go through 2,105 documents. Several accused persons have not yet been apprehended.” Read more
Bombay High Court seeks NIA response to plea by 4 accused for default bail
01/03/2023
Bar & Bench / by Neha Joshi
The four accused have challenged an order of a special NIA court rejecting their default bail pleas. They sought parity with Sudha Bharadwaj, a co-accused who was granted default bail by the High Court in 2021.
The Bombay High Court on Wednesday issued notice to the National Investigation Agency (NIA) on a plea for default bail filed by four persons accused in the Bhima Koregaon case [Mahesh Raut & 4 others v. National Investigation Agency]. Read more
4 accused seek bail from Bombay HC on parity with Sudha Bharadwaj
02/03/2023
India Today / by Vidya
Four accused in the Elgar Parishad case sought bail in the Bombay High Court on parity with Sudha Bharadwaj, who was granted default bail in 2021 in the same case.
The Bombay High Court has issued notice to the National Investigation Agency (NIA) and sought a reply to the bail petition of four Elgar Parishad accused – Mahesh Raut, Sudhir Dhawale, Shoma Sen and Rona Wilson. Read more
Bombay High Court seeks NIA’s stance on request by Surendra Gadling to argue his bail plea in person
01/03/2023
Bar & Bench / by Neha Joshi
Through a letter, Gadling had told the Court that it would be difficult to brief his legal aid lawyer about the case since the chargesheet was voluminous and since prison meetings are permitted only for about 20 minutes.
The Bombay High Court on Wednesday sought the assistance of the National Investigation Agency (NIA) to decide whether the Court should allow Surendra Gadling, an accused in the Bhima Koregaon case, to appear in person before the High Court to argue his default bail application. Read more
To allow or not allow Surendra Gadling to argue his own case, Bombay HC deliberates
01/03/2023
India Today / by Vidya
The HC bench has asked the advocate representing the NIA to discuss the issue with the investigating agency and revert.
The Bombay High Court on Wednesday deliberated for long whether advocate Surendra Gadling should be granted permission to appear in person before the court to make his submissions for default bail. Read more
Supreme Court hears bail pleas of Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira / Delay in the process
The Supreme Court continues hearing bail pleas of activists Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira, accused in the Bhima Koregaon case. Matter before Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia.
Sr Adv Rebecca John appearing for Gonsalves takes Court through documents relied on by the prosecution.
…
Sr Adv R Basant for Ferreira: I am in the next matter. I shall not repeat what my friend said. I have been in custody for over 4 years. In custody since 28.8.2018.
…
Hearing to continue on Friday.
John: They are looking for the elusive ‘goli’.
Senior advocate Rebecca M. John, appearing for Gonsalves, argued that the documents relied on by the NIA as evidence fail to prove Gonsalves’ connection with the alleged offence.
On Tuesday, a division bench of the Supreme Court, comprising Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia, heard arguments on behalf of trade unionist, activist and academic Vernon Gonsalves for the grant of regular bail. Gonsalves, and activist and lawyer Arun Ferreira have filed bail applications at the Supreme Court challenging the order of the Bombay High Court dated October 15, 2019, rejecting their bail pleas.
… The matter is posted for further hearing tomorrow, March 1. Read more
‘No Incriminating Material Found Against Me’: Bhima Koregaon Accused Vernon Gonsalves Tells Supreme Court Seeking Bail
28/02/2023
Live Law / by Awstika Das
To deny bail on the basis of the little evidence that the centre has against Bhima Koregaon-accused Vernon Gonsalves was a ‘stretch’, said senior advocate Rebecca John, appearing on behalf of the jailed activist. “There is no evidence,” said John, after taking the court through the documents on which the National Investigation Agency relied…
A division bench of Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia was hearing the bail applications of Gonsalves and a co-accused, Arun Ferreira, both of whom have been lodged in jail since August 2018 for offences under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967. Read more
Gautam Navlakha Not Involved With Maoist Party, Rather Suspected By Them To Be A ‘Govt Agent’: Lawyer Tells Bombay High Court
28/02/2023
Live Law / by Sharmeen Hakim
The Communist Party of India (Maoist) suspected senior journalist Gautam Navlakha was a “government agent” who negatively impacted their movement, his counsel argued before the Bombay High Court on Monday.
He cited a document seized from co-accused researcher Rona Wilson’s laptop to demonstrate the CPI(M)’s contempt for Navlakha is diametrically opposite from the UAPA charges NIA has levelled against him of “deep involvement in the activities of the CPI(Maoist) party,” and of connections with the ISI and separatist movement of Kashmir. Read more
Gautam Navlakha seeks bail, cites delay in commencement of trial
28/02/2023
India Today / by Vidya
Gautam Navlakha, an accused in the Elgar Parishad case, sought bail in the Bombay High Court on Monday. Navlakha sought bail after citing a delay in the commencement of the trial.
Gautam Navlakha, an accused in the Elgar Parishad case, sought bail in the Bombay High Court, citing a delay by the prosecution in filing a reply on the discharge application argued months ago.
Highlighting the issue, Yug Mohit Chaudhari representing Navlakha, submitted that there was no prospect of a trial in the case to commence in the near future, adding Navlakhha’s discharge application was argued months ago, but the prosecution is yet to file its reply. Read more
Elgar Parishad case: Proof against Navlakha is his own articles, HC told
28/02/2023
Hindustan Times / by HT Correspondent
The bench was further informed that the applicant was criticised by the government as well as the Maoists for his critical articles were a sure sign of his independence.
The Bombay high court, while hearing the regular bail application of Elgar Parishad accused Gautam Navlakha, was informed that the incriminating evidence showing his connection with the banned CPI (Maoist) group was the articles which he had written as a journalist. Read more
No allegation of Gautam Navlakha committing any act of violence, lawyer tells HC
27/02/2023
National Herald / by pti
A division bench of Justices A S Gadkari and P D Naik is hearing the arguments on the bail plea, and the same will continue on Tuesday.
There is no allegation against Gautam Navlakha of committing any “act of violence” in the voluminous chargesheet filed in the Elgar Parisha-Maoist links case, the activist’s lawyer told the Bombay High Court on Monday.
While arguing for the activist’s bail, the lawyer also said that there was no prospect of the trial in the case to commence in the near future. Read more
[Bhima Koregaon – Elgar Parishad Case]
Bombay High Court is hearing senior journalist Gautam Navlakha’s plea for regular bail. He is currently under house arrest.
Hearing before the bench of Justices AS Gadkari and PD Naik.
Adv Yug Mohit Chaudhary for Navlakha.
Chaurdhry – There are four compilations. In the bail application I have included everything that’s in the charge sheet that I could file against the applicant.
HC – There are three orders of the HC, which one correctly mentions the basic facts?
Chaudhry – I will get back.
Chaudhry – The applicant is 74 yrs. Accused No. 11. He surrendered on 14.4.2020 to NIA in Delhi after his ABA was rejected.
He has been in custody for three years and he is presently under house arrest pursuant to SC’s orders.
Chaudhry – He has been chargesheeted under sections 153A, 120B…
Chaudhry continues correcting the sections from the record.
HC – Where are the actual charges?
Chaudhry – Charges have not been framed. But let us take every word in the chargesheet.
Chaudhry – The four grounds are…
1. THERE is not a single allegation of committing ANY act of violence. Since there is no association of violence in the allegations, then no offence punishable under chapter 4 of UAPA made out.
Chaudhry – The basic ingredient for invocation of chapter 4 of UAPA is a commission, association, abetment or conspiracy to commit a terrorist act. That is not even alleged in this case.
Chaudhry – Therefore nothing involving life imprisonment is even attracted .. at the highest only section 38 & 39 of UAPA may be attracted if the chargesheet is taken as it is. Section 20 of UAPA is not attracted at all.
Chaudhry – There is no description of a terrorist act in this 54 volume chargesheet. There has to be something. It cannot be just imagination.
Chaudhry – Their answer always is he possesses the Maoist Constitution. Can that be a terrorist act? I have written articles critical of Maoist violence. I am a writer and a scholar.
by Bar & Bench (Feb 21, 2023)
++ #SupremeCourt to shortly hear bail pleas by Bhima Koregaon accused Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira who are facing charges under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 for alleged Maoist links. ++
++ Pass-over granted, at the behest of the Additional Solicitor-General. To be taken up later today. ++
++ Bench about to rise for lunch.
Senior Advocate Rebecca John: We have informed the other side, I have some difficulty after lunch. Can it be listed next Tuesday?
Bench: Alright, next Tuesday. Feb 28. ++
Supreme Court Adjourns Bail Applications Of Vernon Gonsalves & Arun Ferreira To Feb 21
13/02/2023
Live Law / by Awstika Das
The Supreme Court on Monday adjourned the hearing of the bail applications of Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira, both of whom have been lodged in jail since August 2018 after their arrest over alleged Naxal links in Bhima Koregaon case. The accused are facing charges under the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967.
A division bench comprising Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia stated in the order: “Accommodation has been sought on behalf of the solicitor-general. List the matter as the first item on Tuesday, February 21.” Read more
The Supreme Court to shortly hear bail applications of activists Vernon Gonsalves and Arun Ferreira in the Bhima Koregaon case.
Matter before Justices Aniruddha Bose and Sudhanshu Dhulia.
Justice Bose: Mr SG, Your junior is saying it will take some time. Should we keep it tomorrow?
SG: Could it be next week?
Justice Bose: That is too long a time.
Sr Adv Rebecca John: Can it be today? SG: That is difficult.
SC: First item Thursday after the fresh matters.
Justice Dhulia: We are told (by court staff) that we cannot have it on Thursday.
John: I have waited so long. I can wait till Tuesday.
Order: List on next Tuesday.
NIA highlights Gautam Navlakha’s ‘Pakistani connect’ to oppose bail in Elgar Parishad case
21/02/2023
India Today / by Vidya
The National Investigation Agency (NIA) has opposed the bail plea of Elgar Parishad accused Gautam Navlakha, claiming that he was an active member of banned terror outfit CPI (Maoist) and had links with a Pakistani secret agent.
The NIA said that Gautam Navlakha sought clemency for an ISI (Inter-Services Intelligence) agent, who was arrested in the US, in an American court…
The bench of Justices AS Gadkari and PD Naik will be hearing Navlakha’s petition on February 27. Read more
Gautam Navlakha was introduced to Pakistan ISI General for recruitment, NIA tells Bombay High Court
21/02/2023
Bar & Bench / by Neha Joshi
The agency claimed that Navlakha was working in urban areas to unite intellectuals against government forces to defeat them “both physically and otherwise.”
Activist Gautam Navlakha was introduced to a Pakistan Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI) General for his recruitment, which shows his nexus to the organisation, the National Investigation Agency (NIA) told the Bombay High Court on Tuesday. Read more
By Bar & Bench (March 30):
